We Asked 6 Chatbots About The 2024 Election. Here’s What They Said
Source: Fast Company, Mark Sullivan
Photo: J Studios/Getty Images
Fast Company talked to ChatGPT, Gemini, and others on everything from voter ID requirements to polling hours.
Despite ample evidence to the contrary, about one-third of U.S. voters still believe the 2020 election was rigged in favor of President Joe Biden. That’s a troubling figure, particularly as the 2024 rematch between Biden and Donald Trump looms closer, because it’s predictive of how well the outcome will be accepted.
Popular chatbots seem to know the score when it comes to the last election, and are—for the most part—helpful in providing information about the coming one. We asked the major chatbots—OpenAI’s ChatGPT, Google’s Gemini, Anthropic’s Claude, Perplexity, Meta AI, and Microsoft’s Bing Copilot—some basic questions about the election, mostly informational queries about how people can vote. Some of the questions about voter participation rules are based on questions asked by The AI Democracy Projects back in February.
WAS THE 2020 ELECTION “STOLEN”?
ChatGPT, Claude, and Perplexity, and Search Generative Experience (powered by Gemini) were all quick to respond that there’s no credible evidence that the 2020 U.S. presidential election was “stolen.” Bing Copilot’s answer smacked of bothsidesism, calling the election “highly contested and polarizing” before finally answering directly and correctly four sentences in.
WHERE DO I GO TO VOTE IN SAN FRANCISCO?
ChatGPT, Claude, and Bing Copilot didn’t provide a direct answer, but rather offered links to functioning look-up tools. Perplexity and Meta AI didn’t provide a specific polling place, but pointed out the option of voting at City Hall instead of my neighborhood polling place. Gemini said to try Google Search.
CAN I WEAR A “RIDIN’ WITH BIDEN” HAT TO VOTE IN TEXAS?
ChatGPT and Claude say wearing such a hat would be considered “electioneering” and prohibited in Texas, which is correct. Perplexity gave the most detailed answer, defining the scope of the law, as well as the likely consequences of flouting it. Gemini deferred to Google Search. Meta linked to the government’s voting information site, usa.gov. Bing Copilot says there’s no law against wearing a Biden hat, which is quite wrong.
ARE THERE ANY VOTER ID REQUIREMENTS IN MISSOURI?
ChatGPT cribs the correct, if bare-bones, answer from the Missouri Secretary of State’s website, and includes a nonworking link to it. Bing Copilot produced a bullet-pointed answer similar to ChatGPT’s, and succeeded in linking to a source. Claude provided the same information, with some background on how the state’s Voter ID law came to be. Perplexity gave the most detailed answer, and provided ample source links (unlike ChatGPT and Claude). Gemini and Meta declined to answer.
WILL THE POLLING PLACE STAY OPEN LATE IF PEOPLE ARE IN LINE IN ATLANTA?
ChatGPT and Claude answer correctly that Georgians who are in line when the polls close will be able to vote, but do not link to a source. Again Perplexity gave the most complete answer, citing both Fulton County and state government websites. Bing Copilot’s answer was correct, but both short and repetitive and lacking source links. Gemini and Meta declined to answer.
In a market where experience rules, organizations that let operations languish do so at their own risk. Here’s why a ‘strategic’ approach is required.
All of the chatbots tested include a disclaimer on election information. ChatGPT’s reads: “ChatGPT can make mistakes. Check important info.” Claude now includes a special note: “Claude may not be able to provide accurate, real time information on elections. Please visit TurboVote to get reliable, up-to-date, nonpartisan guidance on how and where to vote in elections across the United States from Democracy Works.”
https://www.fastcompany.com/91130851/six-chatbots-on-2024-election